The
UNRELIABLE NARRATOR:
Who is
the reliable narrator? Sid tells the story. To me, Chip is the one who betrays his friend,
publicly, cruelly, in the documentary. In their younger days, Sid
recalls Chip stealing from his own family members. In their Berlin
and Paris days, Chip plays the Iago, teasing Sid about the woman he
loves and her concern for Hiero. Sid seems believable where it
concerns memory, plot, what happened, but he is less strong,
unreliable, when it comes to interpreting his own and others'
feelings. "Trust the tale, but not the teller." He is
immature and insecure, and seems only to come of age in his eighties
when he finally sees Hiero again. What Sid did to Hiero, withholding
the papers, was morally wrong, a lie of omission which, if he had
told Hiero that the papers had arrived, would have allowed Hiero to
make his own informed life or death decision about when to flee
Paris. Sid chose to put their art, the possibility of musical
immortality, ahead of his friend's safety.
No comments:
Post a Comment